Sandra - re http://www.fivedoves.com/letters/sep2012/sandraj929-2.htm your comments are noted and that is an argument that I have read before. especially point three, which I think is very logical, and make break the Departure = Catching away argument. thanks for those Jack Kelley notes. I have no predisposition on this. My notes are what they are, an initial review of the number 863 and what it appears to be to me at this given point in time. http://www.fivedoves.com/letters/sep2012/clay922.htm If the Departure is, indeed, an Doctrinal Apostasy event, then is it worldwide? regional? denominational? is it just talking about the backslidden believers in the West? specifically the USA? is it talking about the Seed-fath movement? is it talking about the prosperity movement? is it talking about the miracles dont ahppen any more because the Apostles all died out movement? does it, or did it happen on a specific day? or did it happen over a generation? did it happen on 9-11? how can a believer know that this has happened, so that their minds are put at ease about it as Paul wanted them to be?