K.S. Rajan (1
June 2013)
"SAME-SEX MARRIAGE:
THE NEW NORMAL"
PARIS -- An estimated (by police) 150,000 people took to the
streets of the French capital last Sunday to protest "le
marriage pour tous." That is "marriage for everyone," the
same-sex legislation signed into law last week by President
Francois Hollande. Meanwhile, in the south of the country, the
Palme d'Or, the highest honor of the Cannes Film Festival, was
awarded to a film called "Blue Is the Warmest Color," a long and
very explicit film about a teenager's wakening lesbianism.
Both happenings could be considered surprising or just another
sign that France is not so gay these days. That's a double
entendre, of course. "Gay Paree!" is not all that comfortable
about gay marriage. I was at the demonstration "La Manif pour
tous," meaning "Demonstration for Everyone." The Paris crowd was
organized, more or less, by the Catholic Church and conservative
political groups. French Catholics, who rarely actually go to
Mass anymore, seemed mostly concerned that gay marriage would
lead to more adoptions of children by same-sex couples.
In fact, though a few hundred "casseurs" -- "breakers" -- broke
windows and banged on cars at the end of the Paris
manifestation, the great danger on the streets was being hit by
"poussettes" -- baby strollers. The protesting crowd was a
Sunday family affair.
Also, some of the demonstrators may have been there to shout
about President Hollande, the most unpopular French leader in
memory. This all happened within the month the French economy
officially slipped back into recession -- not a good time for a
leader raising income taxes and establishing wealth taxes. That
tax, if you noticed, was the reason that Gerard Depardieu, the
country's most popular film star, moved to Chechnya. (There is
no doubt that some less famous Frenchmen and women, and
foreigners too, are leaving the country because of the Hollande
taxes.)
Europe, oddly, seems to be having more trouble accepting
same-sex marriages -- even in countries where heterosexual
couples with children often don't bother to go through any
formal church or civil weddings. Go figure.
In Italy, same-sex marriage is illegal and is going to stay that
way for a long time. Still, Giuseppe and Massimiliano, famously
in the press, went through a totally extra-legal ceremony last
week in Rome with family members cheering them on. In England, a
tangling Parliament is pushing through amendments to legalize,
or not legalize, same-sex marriage.
While watching all this happening, I happened to be quietly
reading "The Trust," Alex Jones and Susan Tifft's 1999 book on
the growth of The New York Times. In one of many memorable
scenes, Adolph Ochs, the Tennessee merchant who made the paper
the greatest in the United States, if not the world, presided at
an editorial board meeting in the 1920s and vetoed a proposal to
write about same-sex couplings. Leaving the meeting with his
son-in-law and successor, Arthur Hays Sulzberger, the old man
asked, "What is a lesbian?"
Well, it's all in the Cannes prize-winning film, selected by a
jury headed by, of all people, Steven Spielberg, which for the
first time gave the award not only to the director, Abdellatif
Kechiche, but to the female co-stars as well. Critics from the
United States doubted many Americans would sit through the
movie. But who knows?
Two days later, the first same-sex wedding between Vincent and
Bruno was, with great publicity and 600 guests, held in the
southern city of Montpellier, called the San Francisco of
France. There will be more. As of now, 14 countries, 12 American
states and the District of Columbia have made same-sex unions
legal. It's too late for demonstrations. This is another new
normal