Donna Danna (9 Feb 2025)
"TO NANSINGS: Why Elijah's Spirit Was Not Reincarnated Into John The Baptist's Body"


This is in reply to you 2/02 post  Reply to Donna Danna re Elijah & John the Baptist

Paul in 2 Corin. 5:8 says, "..to be absent from the body and to be present with the Lord." If a believer dies, they are absent from their body and present with the Lord.  If a believer has an out of body experience like you did while you were alive, you were absent from the body and present with the Lord.  Elijah was taken alive to heaven so his body, soul and spirit were present with the Lord.  So if Elijah was taken out of his body up in heaven, he still would be present with the Lord and not reincarnated into the body of John the Baptist at birth.  According to the Hindu and Buddhist religions, a person has to die first before their soul is reincarnated into another body. Elijah never died, and his body, soul, and spirit remained up in heaven until he was seen talking to Jesus on the mount of transfiguration. He will return to Earth again as one of the two witnesses, be killed, and then resurrected after 3 and 1/2 days.

As for your notion that while the adult Elijah was alive up in heaven that the Lord took his soul and put it into John the Baptist at birth and if reincarnation was true (which it isn't) then Elijah's soul would not be able to be put back into his own body because he wasn't about to be born which is when reincarnation takes place. Elijah's soul would have to be put into another person's body about to be born. Then Elijah in his alive adult body up in heaven wouldn't be able to come back as one of the two witnesses because his soul would be missing from his body. 

And yes, I realize that you think that the Lord took Elijah's soul out of his body while he is alive up in heaven and put it into John the Baptist's body at birth where it stayed there for about 34 yrs., and likely you think the Lord put Elijah's soul back into his body up in heaven when John the Baptist died. You are the only person that I know that thinks that because when a believer is absent from the body, they are present with the Lord and not present in someone else's body.

The article below lists a number of early Christian writers who did not believe in reincarnation:

Here is another article as well.

Below is also a 195 page article telling why reincarnation is not a Christian belief.