OH, ARE NO HEATHEN AND SET ME APART FROM HELL'S is an anagram for "AND HE SHALL SEPARATE THEM ONE FROM ANOTHER." (Matt 25:32)
HE SET ME APART is an anagram for "SEPARATE THEM." (Matt. 25:32)
DIVIDETH, HE HAS SPARED HIS SHEEP is an anagram for "AS A SHEPHERD DIVIDETH HIS SHEEP." (Matt. 25.32)
OH, TAG, SET FROM is an anagram for "FROM THE GOATS." (Matt. 25:32)

THEN HIGH HEARTED SONSHIP is an anagram for "THE SHEEP ON HIS RIGHT HAND."
THE FELON BUTT is an anagram for "BUT ON THE LEFT." (Matt. 25:33)
HE'S TO TAG is an anagram for "THE GOATS." (Matt. 25:33)

SEVER, RAGE LIFT IN or SEVER, A FILTERING are 2 anagrams for "EVERLASTING FIRE." (Matt 25:41)
SIGN - HE'D HELD EVIL SATAN is an anagram for "THE DEVIL AND HIS ANGELS." (Matt. 25:41)

HADES NET is an anagram for "AND THESE."  (Matt. 25:46)
GO ALLAH'S WAY is an anagram for "SHALL GO AWAY."  (Matt. 25:46)
EVIL NETS MAN, HE TURNS INTO PIG is an anagram for "INTO EVERLASTING PUNISHMENT."  (Matt. 25:46)
BUT THE HOT INTEGRIOUS, LIFE ETERNAL or BUT HERE SOUGHT IT, LIFE ETERNAL are two anagrams for "BUT THE RIGHTEOUS INTO ETERNAL LIFE."  (Matt.25:46)